Wandsworth Welcomes Refugees presents an evening of film, stories and comedy:
‘Refugee Stories – surviving and celebrating’
Tuesday May 9th, 7pm at the Sound Lounge, Tooting
Wandsworth Welcomes Refugees was formed a year ago to bring together people, organisations and faith groups in Wandsworth who want to support refugees here and abroad.
We’re presenting our first Wandsworth Arts Fringe event at the wonderful Sound Lounge venue in Tooting. Its a new venue on Tooting High Street with a great atmosphere and bar.
Wandsworth Welcomes Refugees presents an evening of film, stories, comedy and music.
Film: Dena Arya & Kyla Simone Bruce will introduce their short documentary on what happened to refugees after the Calais ‘Jungle’ was demolished.
Stories: Shabibi Shah, who captured her flight from Afghanistan in a gripping memoir “Where do I belong?” & currently fosters refugee children, will be interviewed by Marion Molteno, a local writer who worked with refugees for 30 years and whose work includes the award-winning “A shield of coolest air” about Somali refugees in London.
Comedy: Edinburgh Fringe sensation Little Soldier Productions will present “Expect Fireworks” on the theme of: So you want to change the world?
Schools are potentially facing many different funding pressures, including raising salaries and National Insurance payments, on-going reduction in support from Wandsworth Council and and a proposed reduction in budgets for London schools under the ‘fairer funding’ changes. The government should be valuing education more and be funding the costs needed by schools to provide the educational outcomes expected, not cutting budgets.
Increasing costs already mean tough choices for Headteachers and are a threat for support for music and the arts, trips out of school and for children with additional needs such as for children with disabilities or needing English language support.
Local parents are understandably concerned and want to take action. We hope that enough pressure from people will change the proposals. Please take a couple of minutes to sign the open letter from Dr Rosena Allin-Khan MP to the Education Secretary. Follow this link to sign up, and you can click on your local school to find out more about how much the proposed cuts will be: drrosena.co.uk/schools
Rosena says: ‘As a result of the Government’s National Funding Formula scheme, Wandsworth schools are facing £15 million in cuts. This is equivalent to over 300 teachers’ salaries.
We have a number of outstanding schools across Tooting and Wandsworth and if these cuts are allowed to go through, they risk moving backwards.
I am calling on the Government’s Education Secretary to support our schools, instead of making these devastating cuts.
I can’t believe how fast this month has gone. I feel as though the kids have only just gone back to school and yet its nearly half term. The news is full of Brexit and Trump (don’t get me started) but lots has been going on in the little patch of London we call home too.
Your local Labour councillors – Dr Rosena Allin-Khan MP and Fleur Anderson
Here’s some news on the new Neighbourhood Plan and how you can make decision about our local streets, Newlands Estate issues, a peoples uprising on Carminia Road, a cycle parking win, the traffic lights on Ritherdon Road (grrrr), results of our local survey, the opening of a new arts venue on Tooting High Road, and a change to our councillor surgeries.
Yesterday over 5,000 people in Tooting had signed the petition against inviting Donald Trump for a state visit. The same number of people (coincidently) living in Wandsworth were born in one of the 7 countries banned from visiting the US (in the 2011 census), and all of their families would also be affected raising the number to many more thousands of people. There are especially important links for people living in Wandsworth for example between the Somali communities here and in Minnesota. The American Embassy will soon be moving to Wandsworth and as a Council we should write to the Ambassador and ask him to oppose this ban. Wandsworth Welcomes Refugees supporters were out in force at the protest at 10 Downing St on Monday.
Wandsworth Welcomes Refugees banner at the Trump protest on Monday
It is important that we oppose this, and use this opportunity to reaffirm how much we value diversity in Balham and Tooting, how we want to live together and not separately and how much being a global community enriches our lives. The Labour councillors will be raising this in the Council meeting tomorrow. Here is the petition on the state visit.
Local neighbourhoods are now allowed to develop a neighbourhood plan. This goes to a vote of all local residents in the area and informs future planning decisions by the Council. Our Tooting one is the first in Wandsworth and has kicked off with the creation of a local Forum who will put together the plan in conversation with as many people as possible. For more information and to say if you agree with this or not click here to see this current council consultation which closes on February 20th. Here is the news story about the launch.
All smiles as we start to create our local neighbourhood plan
I’m on the organising group which is keen for the whole process to be inclusive, creative and inspire us to think about how we can see a difference in our local area. Rosena and I are both on the Forum and do ask us if you have any questions or would like to get more involved – we’d love to have more people on the group.
Newlands Estate issues – Treherne Court and Baringer Square
Fleur with residents Charles and Patricia, and council officers
Thanks to all the residents of Newlands Estate (off Franciscan Road and Tooting Bec Road) for raising various issues in meetings and emails. In response I organised a visit with the local Area Housing Manager and the cleaning services company. There are lots of anti social behaviour concerns, and issues with parking, trees, fly tipping, a whole strip of abandoned gardens, and crime. I hope that action will be taken on all of these and will working with council officers and our safer neighbourhood team to tackle all of these.
On a positive note we saw the planned area for a community garden and we’ll be supporting
Are for proposed community garden
residents to get funding for this. The plan is to have a picnic bench and some fruit trees – other ideas and sharing examples of good community gardens are very welcome.
Peoples power on Carminia Road
People living on Carminia Road were fed up with rubbish dumped in front of some garages on their road and I met with them and demanded action. As a result the council took action and the landlord cleared the rubbish within two weeks. Do get in touch with me if you have something that you want to get sorted out on your road and lets see what we can do.
A cycle parking win
More of these please
Its not earth shattering but it is good news. Mike lives locally and came to me when his bike was stolen outside Trinity Pharmacy on Balham High Road. I supported him to write a petition for cycle parking hoops at the pharmacy which lots of customers signed. It took a few more months and follow up requests but finally Transport for London did agree and here they are. With continuing increases in cycling we need to see more and more parking for bikes whereever possible.
Traffic lights on Ritherdon Road
Thank you to everyone who has got in contact with me to complain about the new phasing of lights on Ritherdon Road and the knock on effect this is having on other local roads as driver try to avoid the longer queues and speed down side roads. I’ve been in contact with Transport for London and the council and hope that the phasing can be returned to the pre-road works times.
Hannah and Keiron have followed their dream, got the crowd funding needed and have now opened a brand new arts and music venue, Sound Lounge. Its on the High Road past the Royal Oak and in the shop that used to be Dreamland and more recently had the big photo of Tooting Common. The launch night was great and they have a schedule of bands and day time activities (yoga, baby groups etc) up to at least October. Here is their website – with a great video by them explaining the whole vision (clue: its not just a new pub): http://www.thesoundlounge.org.uk
Results of our local survey
Thank you to everyone who filled in the local survey that we sent around with our Christmas cards. The top issues that concern people in the area are…… street cleaning and flytipping, and crime. We’ll be taking all your comments and continuing to raise these issues with the council and taking action on your behalf.
Change to our councillor surgeries
Rosena at our new drop in surgery venue – main issues raised were housing
We’ve changed our local surgery times from being in Balham library to being on the first Wednesday of every month from 10.15 – 11.15 in the Scout hall opposite Du Can Court and on the corner of Balham High Road and Elmfield Rd (the leisure centre road). Its drop in so do just turn up. Thank you to Network Neighbourhood who have a coffee morning at that time for hosting us – so you can get a drink and meet other local people at the same time. You can email us anytime too:
The planned new path will have a gravel surface like this existing path on the Common.
There is a proposal to widen the existing path on Tooting Common that goes from the cafe to the Lido and make it a shared cycle and pedestrian path. Just over 150 responses have been received so far, which doesn’t seem many. Thanks to the council officers who braved the cold for the drop-in session last week. Thanks to everyone who stopped to talk too. Of those I spoke to there are mixed opinions, but with a majority in favour but with concerns about some cyclists going too fast. Better signs were asked for by several people. But what do you think?
Rosena and Fleur had a wonderful evening celebrating some of the amazing people who make Tooting such a great place to live. The Balham and Tooting Community Awards went to some local heroes such as the Tooting Park Rangers football team coaches who have turned a dads kick about on the common into a five league teams. Its still open to all players and a wonderful community group with a dedicated team of coaches who really deserve this award.
BACTA local heroes awards ceremony
Another wonderful team honoured were the Little Village volunteers who have set up a growing charity which provides baby clothes and equipment to people who couldn’t otherwise afford them. Have a look at their Little Village HQ website.
What, still no cycle parking?
The Transport for London roadworks have finished at last on the High Road, but left me baffled about why they happened as there was a lot of work done to slightly widen the pavement. There were lots of concerns about safety on the road, with a spate of motorbike accidents, so I hope that these changes were in response to concerns about that. However we still don’t have the cycle parking outside Trinity Pharmacy that residents presented a petition to ask for following several thefts of bikes.
The new phasing of the Ritherdon Road lights has increased traffic jams backing up. We’ll be taking both up with Transport for London.
Homelessness rising in Wandsworth
A major concern is the ever increasing amount of homelessness in Tooting and we are working to support increasing numbers of families who have housing problems. When I became a councillor in 2014 there were 791 people in temporary accommodation, and now there are 1309 people. This costs the council over £3million last year – placing many people outside the borough often as far away as Wembley – in very small and unsuitable and yet costly hostels. The council has not got any solutions to this problem, and more families are left commuting for hours to schools and jobs and living for far too long in unsuitable hostels. Meanwhile big developments are continuing without enough social (council) housing at rents people can afford, and enough really affordable housing – instead of slightly less expensive housing which is labelled ‘affordable’ but isn’t.
Surgery move to Scout Centre on Wednesdays
When we elected in 2014 we immediately started up a monthly Bedford ward surgery in Balham library. We’ve reviewed this surgery and want to make it more accessible, so we’re moving to Southside Scout Centre on Wednesday mornings and hope that this will be easier to get to for more people. It will be on the first Wednesday of every month, no appointment is needed, and it is opposite Du Cane Court on the High Road at the junction with Elmfield Road. We’re happy to meet with you at another time by appointment too – just email us. Thanks to the Neighbourhood Network group for hosting us – you can have a cup of tea with your neighbours as well as coming to see your councillors.
This newsletter is packed with latest news on the Balham and Tooting local heroes event, Tooting Common trees and cycling, planning applications for Bedford Hill Old Church and Foxbourne Rd, #TidyUpTooting campaign, serious concerns about St Georges, new Caring kitchen lunch at St Anselms, local crime and TASER use, Balham High Road improvements, and the first Syrian refugee family welcomed to Wandsworth
Do contact Fleur and Rosena if you want to know more or have an issue we can help with: firstname.lastname@example.org and email@example.com
Do you know a local community hero?
Come along – all welcome!
Do you know someone who works for a community group, or helps people in their local area or community, or goes above and beyond in work locally? Now is your chance to celebrate them! Nominations for the Balham and Tooting Community Association (BACTA) community heroes awards are open until November 8th. Please use the online form at http://batca.org/nomination/. The awards go to those you nominate. There’ll be awards both for individual volunteers and teams. The nominations will be assessed by a panel of independent judges.
Awards will be presented on 24th November 2016 at a celebratory evening at Jasmin’s Club, 202 Upper Tooting Road, SW17 7TG, to which all are welcome. Its a really great night, with wonderful food and entertainment, and will make you very proud to live in Balham and Tooting. To book a place, please click here http://batca.org/reserve-place/ the evening is free and supported by the Wandsworth Community Fund – please bring a donation on the night. Do come and invite your friends – why not fill a table?
I’m on the BACTA organising group so if you have any comments about this, or suggestions that BACTA could do to make links and strengthen our community, please email me your ideas.
Tooting Common – Chestnut Avenue trees and Quietway cycle route
The consultation on the future of Chestnut Avenue closed last month and 695 local people had responded, with 74% in favour of replanting the avenue all at once, although 50% of these people also favoured the option of slowly replacing the trees as they continue to face disease. This beautiful avenue is much loved by us all in the area and deciding how to preserve it is very difficult. It is dreadful that so many trees are suffering from a disease that Chestnut Trees all over the country have and is spreading, and one symptom is that branches fall off. So safety is the top priority, and the opportunity for significant investment in replanting the whole avenue rather than let it slowly decline one tree after another. But we also want to save any of these trees that are healthy and do not need to be cut down. At the committee meeting I proposed that the healthy trees (currently 6 trees, but this needs to be assessed again) are not cut down and this was accepted by the committee. The recommendation to replant the Avenue was agreed to by the Community Services Committee and is likely to be carried out in the Winter of 2017/18. A campaign to save the trees is being led by Friends of Tooting Common.
A report about the leaf mining moth and bleeding canker disease affecting Horse Chestnut diseases across the country was recently on Sky News.
The next consultation on the common will be controversial as well. Cross London Quietways cycle routes are being set up, and the Waterloo – Croydon route goes through Tooting Common under current plans. Following responses from the first consultation, Chestnut Avenue is not the proposed route but instead the diagonal path from the cafe to the Lido car park. This would be widened to 3m and a gravel surface used which is good for buggies, wheelchairs and cyclists but discourages fast cycling as it is not as smooth as tarmac.
The consultation distribution plan has been shared with me and I’ve asked for it to be extended to all the road off the Common instead of just some and all of Heritage Park instead of only those closest to the Common. This consultation will be coming out soon so please watch for notices on the Common and have your say.
Old Church on Bedford Hill
We supported the many local objections to the large proposed development of the Old Church on Bedford Hill. The plan was to keep the front but redevelop the rest into 21 flats and a nursery. The planning officers agreed with our objections and the recommendation to refuse this application was agreed by the planning committee. We hope that the developers can return with a plan using the existing building and will be asking from them to involve the local community more in their future planning.
St Anthony’s Court, Foxbourne Rd
There was also a large number of objections to plans by St Anthony’s Court residential home to add another storey to their building. This backs onto the garden’s of six houses in Foxbourne Road and will block a lot of light to the gardens and homes. There will be considerable building traffic going down the narrow road and into the small entrance to the Court, and increased traffic of visitors once built. I represented these concerns at the planning committee, but the application was still accepted on the basis that similar schemes have been agreed to elsewhere in Wandsworth. This seems very unfair and is understandably very disappointing for residents.
For too long we’ve been telling the council to sort out fly tipping and dirty streets, and it is one of the main reasons you get in contact with us as your local councillors. Rosena is gathered your reports for a month and took this to the council who have said they will do more. Click here for Rosena’s letter on #TidyUpTooting. If you see fly-tipping in your street, report it to the Wandsworth ‘report it’ app (if you have a smartphone. More info on the Report It app is here.
Serious concerns about St Georges’ Hospital
At the October council meeting Labour proposed a debate on health outcomes and serious concerns about the financial situation of St Georges. In the motion we called on the Council to affirm its commitment to the NHS as a world-class healthcare system, but note that it is coming under increasing funding pressure, expresses its concern at the various failings in patient safety and care uncovered during the recent Care Quality Commission inspection at St George’s Hospital Trust and notes that the Trust is forecasting an end of year deficit of £55.5 million and that its own corporate risk report describes its overall level of exposure to operational risk as “extreme”, welcome the incredible work that staff at St George’s do but recognises that the Trust is struggling with high turnover and vacancy rates and that the staff survey reports unacceptable levels of bullying and harassment.
Rosena’s gave a strong speech about junior doctors during the debate. Labour councillors called on the Council to show leadership and work with the Trust to ensure that patient care is kept to a high standard. The full motion text is here and we will continue to be extremely concerned about the situation and what it will mean for our healthcare provision.
Roadworks on Tooting High Rd and Balham Boulevard
I’ve been watching the changes to pavements on Tooting High Road and hope that this will result in a safer roads, especially for motorcyclists as we have had several accidents on the road and we lobbied TfL on road safety on this stretch of the High Road – lots of people signed petitions. It is disappointing to see the pavement widened, the cycle track narrowed and the opportunity for a separate cycle lane for cyclists not used.
The plans for a more attractive stretch of High Road up to Balham station have been talked about for years, and TfL will be revealing their plans in a meeting in early November. Lets hope this is better than the last meeting where they said that nothing could be done.
Caring Kitchen at St Anselms
St Anselms Church’s monthly Caring Kitchen is proving very popular and everyone is welcome for a free homemade lunch in a caring environment. the next ones are 29th November and 20th December in St Anselms Old Hall on Tooting High Road from 12.15 – 2pm. For enquires please contact firstname.lastname@example.org
Crime and TASER
The safer neighbourhood team identified Ritherdon Rd as having higher burglary and the local police and safer neighbourhood team visited everyone in the street and provided free DNA marking kits for valuable items.
I went to the Wandsworth Safer Neighbourhood Board and had a update on Wandsworth crime figures, which show that although Wandsworth is doing well compared to other boroughs, violent crime is rising and theft of motorbikes and scooters is a particular problem. In this area its a problem in the streets around Tooting Bec station especially, but even the heaviest bike left on the street is a potential target.
We also had a presentation about TASER gun use in London. It has very strict regulation and is used to prevent violence either to themselves or others by firearms police. At any time, about 4 officers who are allowed to use TASER are on duty in Wandsworth and in the first 6 months of this year it was used 8 times. TASER guns are a sci-fi looking plastic yellow and shoot out electrode barbs which disable people through the electronic pulse rather than through pain and stand for ‘Thomas A Swift Electronic Rifle’.
This was the annual public Safer Neighbourhood Board meeting and a chance for the Borough Commander to be publicly accountable, but it was publicised, the public weren’t involved in setting the agenda and having issues which matter to us, and it was attended by about four members of the public! It was yet another proof of how little the Conservative Council want to work with us all as residents together in Wandsworth.
First Syrian Family welcomed in Wandsworth – more urgent response needed
As the war in Syria and dreadful destruction of Aleppo continues, there is an urgent need for desperate families to move to safety. This certainly makes me feel very fortunate indeed to live in such a safe place. We can provide safe haven for families, and the Home Office has made funding available to local boroughs. Wandsworth took a step forward and welcomed a family of three people from Syria this week. I hope that the response can match the urgency and we can see many more families welcomed before Christmas. Rosena has the council leader how many families will be welcomed by Christmas, but he did not answer this.
Meanwhile, if you can help to support refugees and have anytime on a Monday morning, please go to St Mary’s church near Balham station on the High Road where there is a drop in for refugees for a meal, meeting others and advice organised by the South London Refugee Association.
This newsletter is packed with lots of local news from your Labour Councillors:
Tooting Common: tree consultation, ParkRun, Quietway cycle route, cafe improvements, cricket pitch and fitness equipment
Crossrail2 plans for Balham and Tooting, Bedford Hill Church redevelopment proposal, local Neighbourhood plan, new Headteachers at St Anselms and Ravenstone Schools, Transition Tooting local events, cycle hoops outside Trinity Pharmacy, safer Elmbourne and Hillbury Rds and Rosena’s trip to Calais to support refugees
Tribute to Cllr Sally-Ann Ephson
Cllr Sally Anne Ephson (centre)
We are really sad that our friend and fellow Labour Councillor, Sally-Anne Epson, died recently as a result of Sickle Cell Disease. It was inspirational that she didn’t let having the disease stop her a Queenstown councillor in Battersea. She spoke up strongly for residents in Queenstown and people with disabilities and she was warm and caring and really supportive and encouraging of other councillors. We will always miss her. Sadiq Khan has also paid tribute to her, and we are fundraising for the Sickle Cell Society in her memory.
Future of trees consultation now closed
1. Future of Chestnut Avenue The Tooting Common future of trees consultation closed on September 4th. Earlier in the week there had been over 600 replies. Early in the consultation I asked for leaflets to be sent to local homes, for drop in times for the public to hear from the council’s tree expert and I’m glad that these were agreed to. The options are for a replacement of the whole avenue with a different type of tree, replacement gradually with different trees as the existing diseased trees are removed, or removing all the trees and not replacing them. If the first option is closed by the Community Services Committee, this would be take 6 weeks during the coming Winter.
New ParkRun Director Tom Baker and Fleur after a run
2. ParkRun is here to stay! There was a six month trial period of the timed weekly ParkRuns on Tooting Common every Saturday at 9am. These are very popular, with about 300 people running each week, and agreed to be well run by the cheery volunteers. The trial has been successful and ParkRun will now be a permanent event on the Common – do come down and give it a go!
3. Quietway cycle route Across London new Quietway cycle routes are being planned, aimed at encouraging more people to cycle through creating routes off main roads and for recreational cycling more than faster commuting. This includes a proposed route 5 from Croydon to Waterloo which it is proposed will include the path from the Triangle to Bedford Hill (a cycle route already) and then diagonally from the cafe to the Lido car park, and this could be a rough surface which would discourage fast cycling at the same time as opening up another cycle route across the Common which would be very welcome. There are also concerns about danger caused by cyclists to pedestrians so we’ll be underlining the need to tackle this in mind in our responses.
4. Tooting Common Cafe upgrade at last! The long-awaited extension to the cafe are due to start later this month and to be finished by next March, including new wheelchair accessible public toilets with baby-changing facilities.
5. Cricket Pitch I am on the Tooting Common Management Advisory Committee of local volunteers who advise Enable and the council and take part in monthly meetings. At the September meeting we discussed the future of the artificial cricket pitch near the playground. Some people would like this to be re-instated as a grass cricket square, although I am keen to ensure that the pitch can continue to be used by the variety of cricketers who currently enjoy it.
6. Fitness Equipment I know that there is lot of interest I having a Fitness trail of wooden equipment on the common (like Wandsworth Common). The council has agreed to this but not to paying for it and I will continue to raise this at the MAC and with Wandsworth council.
7. Crossrail 2 – decisions ahead. We are firmly ‘Rooting for Tooting’ continuing to campaign for CrossRail to come to Tooting and Rosena and Rosena has met Michelle Dix, Head of Crossrail 2. We have been told that a recommendation for Tooting or Balham would be expected in the Autumn and then a further consultation on the new proposal.
8. Bedford Hill Church redevelopment opposed During the summer plans for a redevelopment of the former Church and Centre for the Deaf on Bedford Hill were published. This is for a redevelopment into 21 flats and a nursery, keeping the front of the church but not the remainder or the distinctive steeple. 70 objections were received, including from many local residents whose gardens have views of the rear of the church, Historic England and the Balham Society. The plans are too large in scale, do not take in account the local historic impact of the building, and lack of local parking would be a serious problem for nearby streets. We welcome more housing, and especially more affordable housing, but hope the developers will change their plans to a smaller number of flats and development within the existing structure.
9. Welcome to new Headteachers at Mrs Elwes at St Anselms School and Mr Croft at Ravenstone School – we’re looking forward to working with you both.
‘Tour de Tooting’ stewards
10. Transition Tooting local events – I enjoyed being a steward on the ‘Tour de Tooting’ cycle event in July and looking forward to the Soup disco tonight as part of the weekend of Tooting Foodival events. Congratulations to Transition Tooting on promoting sustainability and community in Tooting.
11. Cycle hoops outside Trinity Pharmacy When a local resident told me that his bike had been stolen from outside the pharmacy I started asking if cycle hoops could be installed outside so that bikes could be safely locked up. This pavement belongs to Transport for London and in April they said that they could put them in within 3-4 months. They are still not there, but we’re keeping up the pressure – watch this space!
12. Safer Elmbourne and Hillbury Reds Last summer we supported local residents and schools to raise their concerns about local road safety with the Council and several petitions were submitted. Traffic on Elmbourne Rd was monitored during the summer and a report due at the Committee on September 20th. I’ve asked about progress and am disappointed to be told that this won’t go to the September committee. We need more action on road safety by the Council and we’ll continue to make this a priority.
13. Wandsworth Welcomes Refugees and local support for refugees in Calais
Rosena recently went to Calais with a car full of things generously donated by Tooting business and local people and helped the volunteers teams in Calais and raised awareness of the continuing dreadful situation there. Here is her interview on Good Morning Britain. We’re also continuing to actively support Wandsworth Welcomes Refugees and ask Wandsworth Council to step up and provide foster carers for unaccompanied children refugees and homes for some families fleeing the terrifying war in Syria.
Its been great to see so many people at lots of events during the summer, including the Living Streets celebration of the borough-wide 20mph limit, South London refugees summer event, Cloudesdale Rd street party and many more.
Contact us – we’re here to help
We have monthly drop in surgeries at Balham library on the third Saturday of every month from 10am – 11am.
Do you visit Tooting Common? What would you think about plans to replace the trees on Chestnut Avenue? The council has just launched a consultation on the future of the Chestnut Avenue trees, and we’re urging everyone to have their say and let their friends know – the deadline is September 4th.
We have asked for more publicity about this consultation and the Council have agreed that they will now leaflet the streets around the Common and have drop in sessions so that you can ask the experts questions.
The Council are proposing making changes to the Chestnut Avenue trees on Tooting Common. This is the Avenue that runs from the cafe down past the playground, pond and tennis courts and up to Tooting Bec Road. This fine mature avenue of Chestnut trees is over 100 years old and some trees have been found to be diseased.
The consultation documents have useful computer generated images which help to show the difference between the options, but we have some concerns about the consultation.
Do have a look at the consultation and see what you think too. If you’d like more information before deciding, do let us know and we will get this and add to this post for others to see too. There will be drop in times on the Common so you can come and speak with Rosena and I about the consultation, and times you can speak with the tree experts.
We have four other concerns about the consultation documents and have asked the council for answers to the questions below – their response is below.
1. First the tree that fell down during the storms earlier this year had root rot as I understand – was there an investigation into whether others have this too? What was the result?
2. How long would the remaining good trees have before they would die? another 20-30 years? If we did replace as they went rather than all at once, would we have about half and half?
3. It is really helpful to have pictures and I appreciate some more thought has gone into how to present the consultation in a much more interesting and informative way that many other plain documents. However, I think that the pictures are very misleading as the first option to replace as they die is how as a very bare and desolate picture, but would actually be an avenue still, but just with uneven heights of trees. The picture seems to lead the reader away from this as an option if they value tree cover. However, the ‘fell and replace’ option is presented as extremely attractive, and the interim measure of the chopped down trees (and loss of extensive tree cover for decades as the new trees grow) is not illustrated. I am sure that there will be lots of comments about this about to come your way, so would you be able to re-look at these diagrams and maybe add a more attractive one to the ‘replace as and when’ option?
4. Also I know we are going to get lots of complaints about not sending out letters about this to the streets around the Common. There is a lot of emotional attachment to these lovely trees: the setting of many a lovely walk/cycle/conker collection on the Common. If the option to fell and replace is chosen it will have a huge impact on users of the Common and if they haven’t known about the consultation because they’ve been away then they will feel very let down. We will be doing all we can as councillors to publicise this, but could you reconsider the leafletting – not of the whole consultation document but just a short letter to point people to the website and boards on the Common?
If you have any comments or questions do respond to this blog or email us (email@example.com and firstname.lastname@example.org) and please spread the word about the consultation – thanks!!
Thank you for your feedback and I can confirm that we will flyer drop homes around the Common and will be hosting drop-in sessions so residents can speak to the parks services on a one-to-one basis while looking up at the trees themselves. The team will also be handing out surveys to passers by on other occasions and posters are going up in the next few days.
Regarding the tree related issues you raise, firstly the tree that fell down I can confirm that decay of the root system is extremely difficult to detect, because of the very matter of it being underground. We undertook decay detection tests on randomly selected tree stems at close to ground level (for which equipment exists) but the results did not enable us to make any assumptions about the soundness (or otherwise) of the root system deeper down. We therefore did not progress to do the same with all the trees. We will have to wait to observe physical symptoms through regular inspection, which is the normal method. Secondly, regarding the life cycle of the remaining good trees, the issue does not really relate to how quickly the trees will die. Some trees will decline and die due to stresses of Bleeding Canker, Leaf miner and Guignardia, but that is likely to be slow attrition. The problem lies in their structural integrity which is declining quite rapidly, leading to potential structural issues, which would be occasional collapse, or occasional branch failure unless we take preventative action. Obviously we will take preventative action which will be substantial crown reduction or pollarding as necessary. Trees won’t necessarily die but they will need disfiguring attention, and at regular intervals thereafter. It is this issue that will be easiest to address/demonstrate at the on-site walk/talk.
Thank you for raising your concern with the images and as you say they are intended to add interest and be illustrative rather than being precise / true-to life. We think residents will recognise that they are only very basic two dimensional illustrations and we’ve made every attempt to ensure that residents view these alongside the three independent surveys/reports and the detailed commentary explaining the issues and likely outcomes. I can explain that under Scenario A, many trees will have to be repeatedly pollarded year after year as they continue to age/weaken so they will never recover their full size or leaf canopy – that goes some way to explaining why the trees in that image are less ‘leafy’ and attractive. In scenario C – I think we’ve been fair in presenting the two images to show that initially the canopy cover will be limited in the first years. The commentary also states that trees take 20-30 years to reach maturity, although the trees will become a significant landscape feature long before that.
If we were to add a new image at this point it would invalidate the responses received so far and we can’t guarantee these residents would re-take the survey.
We do take your point very seriously and I have examined the survey responses this morning; so far 78.5% of respondents say they are ‘clear about all the issues’, 20% say they are ‘clear about most of issues’ and only 1.9 per cent say they are ‘unclear’. While this isn’t a question specifically about the images it does suggest that overall people are satisfied with the commentary and can understand the independent analysis.
I hope it’s clear that our parks team have tried very hard to present this consultation in an engaging and fair way with very good quality information to support the different options.
The big news recently has been the election of Sadiq Khan as Mayor, Leonie Cooper as our new London Assembly Member and Rosena Allin-Khan as our new Tooting MP. but there has been plenty going on locally too. This newsletter features local street parties, Tooting Common Dog show, Rutherford House and St Anselms school fairs, disappearing bins and parking meters, new Neighbourhood Planning Forum, and the latest planning objections submitted.
Two local meetings coming up:
Tooting Common public meeting on June 28th at 7.30pm at St Anselms School, Louisville Rd. An update from the council, plenty of chance to ask questions and an opportunity to the join the voluntary advisory group. I’m on it so do ask me if you’d like to know more.
Wandsworth Welcomes Refugees public meeting with speaker Alf Dubs and chair John O’Farrell. Thursday 30th June, 7.30pm at East Hill Baptist Church, Battersea, SW18 2HD. Lord Dubs led the recent law on receiving unaccompanied refugee children. There will also be latest news from the Calais camps and what we can do in Wandsworth. To become a member of Wandsworth Welcomes Refugees and have an update on this meeting and other events please email: email@example.com
There were nearly 100 street parties across Wandsworth, and they’ve been great ways to meet neighbours, have a fun day together and celebrate where we live. Congratulations to everyone who organised one for the their street and if you haven’t had one yet its not too late! Wandsworth Council have waived the fee for booking a street party until September.
St Anselms and Rutherford House School Fairs and Tooting Common Fun Dog Show
Tooting Common Dog Show
Huge congratulations to Rutherford and St Anselms Schools for their wonderful school fairs – it takes a lot of work, and everyone enjoyed them so much. Tooting Common fun dog show was also really successful and enjoyed by everyone who came to watch or take part. Thanks to Friends of Tooting Common and compere Leonie Cooper new London Assembly member, and to the Mayor Wandsworth for adding dog show judging to his list of talents!
Rosena and Fleur dodging showers at Rutherford House School Fair
Street bins across Wandsworth being removed
A bin was here (a really boring picture I know – but you get the point)
When I saw that the bins outside St Anselms School on Louisville Road and outside Ravenstone school on Elmfield Rd had disappeared, I asked what was going on. The council has a new policy of taking away bins in public spots across the Borough – clearly a cost cutting policy. I’m very concerned about the impact this will have on our main streets, where there is often too much litter already.
There are very mixed messages from the Council about what can be done. In Chestnut Grove the bin outside the corner shop was put back when local residents complained, but similar requests to replace the missing bins in Furzedown have not been responded to. Councilllor Sue McKinney in Roehampton is seeing the results of the bin removal on Putney Heath and Wimbledon Common. She says:
“I would like to see the litter bins put back at least at the bus stops. Even with your sweeps, the litter unfortunately blows across to the common and is becoming a major concern for the Conservators whom I have spoken to today. They quite simply do not have the man power to see to it.
I am very concerned about the effect litter has on wildlife and would like to see our Wimbledon Common wildlife protected. There are no such issues arising in the part of the Common that stretches into Merton Borough. I have had a report of a fox with its head in a crisp bag running around and bumping into trees in confusion. This fox was impossible to help. Litter severely harms wildlife.
Also our children are taught to put their litter in bins as citizens of the world. How can they do this if there are no litter bins. The majority of people are very litter conscious and therefore we do need to see litter bins back – especially at bus stops and schools.”
Have you noticed a missing bin? Please let me know!
Parking Meter Mess Up
New meter bagged up for weeks – no other one nearby
Motorists have been left very frustrated across Wandsworth as 177 cash parking meters have been replaced with card ones – but a contracting problem means tey can’t be switched on. I have supported a successful complaint over a parking ticket issued on Elmfield Rd which has had no parking meter for weeks at the High Road end, and there were no stickers or alternative payment ofered. I’ve asked the council for an explanation and to know when these machines will be turned on but no yet received an answer.
The old parking meters should not have been taken out when the new ones couldn’t be switched on and people are left wandering up and down streets looking for a marking meter, or facing totally unfair fines. The council needs to take urgent responsibility for this mess up.
New Neighbourhood Forum – taking control of local planning
The government is enabling local groups to create their own neighbourhood plans. These need to be within the London and Wandsworth plans, but could give local people the opportunity to have more say about what is important for them in their area. this could be the type of shops, housing developments, street layouts or use of public buildings and open spaces. A local Tooting Bec and Broadway Neighbourhood Forum is being set up to bring a wide variety of local people together to create a local plan. For more information and to be involved contact: firstname.lastname@example.org
Local planning issues
– Objection made to the proposal for a 18m telephone at the triangle on Tooting Common
– Objection to the additional storey on the Polish old people’s home on Foxbourne Rd
– On-going representations on behalf of Rutherford House parents objecting to more telephone masts on the TA centre nearby, moved from Bedford House which is being redeveloped. The parents and governors have been objecting to this for two years and EE could put the mast on a building nearer to Balham station and further from local schools.
Thank you to everyone who voted for Rosena to be our new MP in Tooting, following Sadiq Khan becoming Mayor of London. It was an intense, short, by-election campaign, and Rosena won with 17,894 votes to Dan Watkin’s (Conservative) 11,537 votes. This is a substantial increase in the Labour majority in Tooting.
For Bedford ward residents, this means that Rosena is both your local Wandsworth ward councillor and your MP. She’ll work hard for you in both roles.
I heard about the murder of Jo Cox whilst I was out canvassing for Rosena in the rain and thunder and was as shocked as everyone else. The two seem so connected with democracy in action as Jo went to her surgery and we were electing a new MP. Jo was an international development campaigner and many people I work with knew her, and together we watched her move from development into politics.
Vigil at Parliament Square
To think that someone felt so violently towards her is too much to understand. The statement by Brendan Cox, her husband, is amazing. To be so lucid, focused on love and inspiring at such a time of huge loss is incredible. As he says we must unite to fight against hatred, wherever and whenever we see it. It has made me reflect on how we conduct politics and redouble my efforts to build a better world in how we relate to each other, in what we stand up for and in building community locally and internationally.
This submission response to Wandsworth council’s consultation and its proposal to de-designate the Garratt Park and Triangle Children’s Centres. We respond in our capacity as local councilors for both Earlsfield and Bedford wards, in which the two children’s centres whose services are under threat are located.
The principle that guides our response is that all parents, no matter which ward they live in, should have access to free early-years childcare. The evidence is very clear: early-years childcare and education boosts our children’s future educational performance, reduces reliance on social care services, helps to tackling childhood obesity, and of course, promotes community cohesion.
We recognise the need for Wandsworth Council to make efficiency savings, including in the provision of early-years childcare across the Borough. We note, however, that Wandsworth has been forced to make these savings as a result of savage cuts to local budgets by this Conservative Government, including the largest real terms cut in the education budget since the 1970s.
We believe that cuts to early years childcare services – especially before all other alternative options have been explored – are a false economy. By making it more difficult for our children to get the best start in life, these cuts run the risk of increasing expenditure further down the line on social services and health.
However, we recognise the need to make immediate savings. Therefore, we support the proposals made in paper 15-437, which by streamlining the management structures of Garratt Park Centre would make significant savings, whilst retaining key services such as stay and play.
The consultation proposal goes much further than the paper voted on in council, paper 15-437. It states that de-designation may result in parents being charged for the use of stay and play services. It also fails to offer any guarantee that important outreach services on the Henry Prince Estate will be maintained.
Therefore, in relation to Garratt Park Centre, we call on the Council:
1. To commit to maintaining free stay and play services in the Garratt Park Children’s centre.
2. To commit to retaining key outreach services on the Henry Prince Estate.
This would be in line with the Council’s original proposals, and would therefore involve the required efficiency savings, but would protect the important work Garratt Park Children’s centre does in an area of high need. We do not think local parents should be punished any further by this Conservative Government.
We note that the argument for retaining services in the Triangle Children’s Centre is somewhat distinct from the Garratt Park Centre. The latter is in an area of high need; whilst the chief importance of the Triangle Centre is its role as a site for community cohesion, attended by parents of all backgrounds.
We are concerned that the changes proposed to the Triangle Children’s Centre will further degrade the service and end up being another children’s activity offer only affordable to the wealthier families in the area. Daily, all afternoon ‘stay and play’ centres are a lifeline for all carers, especially young mums who are often isolated when at home with a small baby or toddler and baby.
Therefore, in relation to the Triangle Centre, we call on the Council:
1. Not to dispose of the lease of the land, so that the cost of a nursery rent to run the service on its own land is passed on to parents.
2. To commit to maintaining free stay and play services in the Triangle Children’s Centre.
We would be happy to discuss these proposals with our Council colleagues, but impress on the Council that there can be no more valuable service than that which provides for our children’s futures.
Councillor Fleur Anderson
Councillor Rachael Stokes
Councillor Rosena Allin-Khan